Equal Housing Opportunity NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice

Licensed Real Estate Broker 95 W Main St, Sayville, NY 11782 Office: (631) 567-0100

Sold

21 Thompson Road Shelter Island, NY 11964

$5,700,000

Listed at $5,875,000. Closed April 7, 2026.

Listing courtesy of Debra L. Von Brook Binder CBR, Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty MLS #KEY906564

Only the front exterior photograph is shown on closed sales, in keeping with OneKey MLS rules.

  • 2Bedrooms
  • 2Bathrooms
  • 1,504Square feet
  • $3,790Per square foot
  • 2022Year built

About this home

Perched 59 feet above sea level for commanding views and peace of mind, this exceptional contemporary estate—designed by noted architect Kenton van Boer—rests on 9.4 private acres, of which 2.7 acres are buildable, and offers 561 feet of premier waterfront on Smiths Cove. Sweeping panoramic vistas of the Sound and the tranquil yacht anchorage set the scene for direct beachfront access and creek frontage along the serene Miss Annie’s Creek—plus the rare opportunity to create your own private dock and mooring. The 1,504-square-foot residence features 2 bedrooms, a study and 2 spa-inspired full baths. A chef’s kitchen anchors the open layout, flowing into a light-filled living room with a stone-accented fireplace and a custom built-in dining area. Thoughtful architectural details by Kenton van Boer. Quartzite flagstone masonry patios and walkways add an additional 1,120 square feet of outdoor living, seamlessly extending the home’s footprint and immersing you in the surrounding natural beauty. Nestled in a serene coastal setting of wood shingles, flagstone patios, and unspoiled shoreline, this property offers unmatched privacy while being just moments from the Shelter Island Ferry to Sag Harbor. A rare blend of seclusion, convenience, and timeless design.

Description supplied by the listing broker.

Features

  • First Floor Bedroom
  • Built-in Features
  • Cathedral Ceiling(s)
  • Chefs Kitchen
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • ENERGY STAR Qualified Door(s)
  • Entrance Foyer
  • High Ceilings
  • Kitchen Island
  • Marble Counters
  • Natural Woodwork
  • Open Floorplan
  • Open Kitchen
  • Pantry

This listing

  1. April 7, 2026 Sold for $5,700,000
  2. August 29, 2025 Listed at $5,875,000

Location

21 Thompson Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Nearby recent sales