Equal Housing Opportunity NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice

Licensed Real Estate Broker 95 W Main St, Sayville, NY 11782 Office: (631) 567-0100

Sold

31 Grand Ave and 20 Spring Garden Ave Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

$2,525,000

Listed at $2,950,000. Closed February 2, 2026.

Listing courtesy of Tina Marika Kaasik, Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty MLS #KEY829868

Only the front exterior photograph is shown on closed sales, in keeping with OneKey MLS rules.

  • 6Bedrooms
  • 4.5Bathrooms
  • 2,640Square feet
  • $956Per square foot
  • 1890Year built

About this home

Historic Shelter Island Heights Home with Pool and Cottage. This beautifully renovated 1890's Victorian home is located in the heart of the Heights Historic District. Ideally located right off the North Ferry, and within a block of the private beach club and tennis courts. And just a stones throw to the Yacht Club. Beautiful architectural details remain throughout the exterior and interior of this Classic Historic home. The main house features 4 Bedrooms with 3 of them having their own balcony thru beautiful arched doorways. The primary bedroom is spacious with a full bath. Gorgeous wide plank pine floors are featured in every room. First floor includes a cozy parlor with fireplace, large den, custom eat-in-kitchen with high-end appliances and easy access to dining area and large wrap around porch for outdoor entertaining. Back deck overlooks the beautiful gardens and heated gunite salt water pool. Beyond the pool is an adorable 2-bedroom guest cottage. Adjacent to the cottage is a detached garage for car, storage, or game room. This home is a Gem. Rare find!

Description supplied by the listing broker.

Features

  • Eat-in Kitchen

This listing

  1. February 2, 2026 Sold for $2,525,000
  2. March 17, 2025 Listed at $2,950,000

Location

31 Grand Ave and 20 Spring Garden Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Nearby recent sales