Equal Housing Opportunity NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice

Licensed Real Estate Broker 95 W Main St, Sayville, NY 11782 Office: (631) 567-0100

Sold

73 Midway Road Shelter Island, NY 11964

$1,600,000

Listed at $1,845,000. Closed August 24, 2026.

Listing courtesy of JoAnn Wind, Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty MLS #KEY929830

Only the front exterior photograph is shown on closed sales, in keeping with OneKey MLS rules.

  • 4Bedrooms
  • 3Bathrooms
  • 2,296Square feet
  • $697Per square foot
  • 1976Year built

About this home

A thoughtfully designed retreat offering peace, privacy, and understated luxury. Tucked away on a private drive in the island's center, you're close enough to bike to all of the island’s beaches or restaurants. The approach sets the tone: a winding drive reveals the house gradually. The home emerges across an expansive lawn, its clean black lines and Anderson windows throughout creating a striking silhouette against the natural canopy. That hammock strung between two trees? Exactly where you'll spend Sunday mornings with coffee and a good read. Inside, the design philosophy is clear: let the outside take the stage. White walls, black accents, and a massive window wall make the front yard feel like your living room's best feature. The newly installed Ortal 110 TS fireplace anchors the open space, a sculptural centerpiece that warms the kitchen, dining, and living areas. Ascoli smart lighting throughout means you can set the color temperature to exactly your liking and automate it to match the rhythms of your day. The kitchen features Robern cabinets, a Thermador gas range, a double oven, and a refrigerator, plus a generous island for preparing all that local fish and farmstand produce. Upstairs, three bedrooms include a primary with an ensuite walk-in shower, a second bedroom with queen-sized built-in bunk beds and clever storage nooks, and a third with expansive windows overlooking the rolling front lawn. A second full bathroom with a tub serves the floor. Downstairs, heated floors make winter mornings civilized. The spacious bathroom features Robern cabinets and heated towel rack, while walk-in closets are generous enough that you and your partner won't need to negotiate territory treaties. Every detail considered, nothing overdone. The fully fenced backyard is its own retreat. Your dog thinks it's paradise. Your green thumb agrees. The newly built backyard office/art studio/yoga sanctuary, properly insulated with new windows and doors, offers a legitimate reason to "work from home" that doesn't involve your kitchen table. Whether it becomes your creative sanctuary, your focus zone, or just where you hide from houseguests, it's ready. The house comes with complete pool plans designed by Glenn Lawton at Spatial Arts. Modern amenities where they matter: EV charger, bike and board storage, without sacrificing the serenity that brought you to Shelter Island in the first place. Even the entrance makes a statement with its sculptural fountain and thoughtfully designed wood and bluestone steps.

Description supplied by the listing broker.

Features

  • First Floor Bedroom
  • First Floor Full Bath
  • Open Kitchen
  • Primary Bathroom
  • Master Downstairs
  • Walk-In Closet(s)

Property details

Interior

Attic
Unfinished
Kitchens
1
Flooring
Ceramic Tile, Hardwood
Levels
Two
Fireplace
Yes
Fireplaces
1
Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Washer

Systems and utilities

Heating
Propane, Radiant, Radiant Floor
Heating zones
2
Cooling
Central Air
Utilities
Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Propane
Water
Well

Exterior and lot

Construction
Wood Siding
Architectural style
Contemporary
Condition
Actual
Parking
Private
Fencing
Back Yard
Patio and porch
Patio

Tax and legal

Parcel number
0700-014-00-03-00-035-005
Tax lot
35.5
Tax block
3
Tax section
14
MLS district
700
Listing agreement
Exclusive Right To Sell

Property details supplied by the listing broker through OneKey MLS, as of August 25, 2026. Fields not shown were not supplied and should not be read as absent from the property.

This listing

  1. August 24, 2026 Sold for $1,600,000
  2. August 24, 2026 Reduced to $1,600,000 from $1,845,000

Location

73 Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Nearby recent sales